The Backroads: BSU in BCS?
By Sean Hart
Saturday, October 17, 2009 8:24 PM PDT
It was 15-14, Boise State, with 11:03 left in the second quarter.
I was late, but I think I showed up about the same time as the No. 5-ranked college football team in the country — if that team ever made an appearance.
And at least I had an excuse: When did college football sell out to the TV gods for a prime time Wednesday game?
No matter. I was tuned in for the rest of the game in front of an old big screen at my rural home in Eastern Oregon. The Broncos had just taken a one-point lead at Ha Chapman Stadium in Oklahoma. And the un-ranked University of Tulsa Golden Hurricane was, surprisingly, still in the game.
After a couple uneventful possessions by both teams, BSU was forced to take a field goal at the end of the half, extending its lead to four points, 18-14. The team ranked fifth in the nation trotted into the locker room less than a touchdown ahead of their Western Athletic Conference rival.
The problem with Boise State’s bid for serious consideration in the Bowl Championship Series — like the National Championship Game — is strength of schedule, the perceived difficulty of the teams BSU must face in its WAC games and pre-season schedule.
While Boise State has been scheduling tougher non-conference opponents the last few years, the fact remains it still primarily plays WAC teams, which are generally not expected to be as competitive as teams from “stronger” conferences.
Playing WAC teams like Nevada, San Jose State and New Mexico State does not help BSU’s chances to be accepted as a team that could compete against perennial powerhouses from the Atlantic Coast, Big East, Ben Ten, Big 12, Pac-10 or Southeastern conferences (those whose champions receive an automatic berth into a BCS bowl).
If Boise State intends to establish itself as a true dynasty program, it should seek to join a stronger conference. Until it does so — or schedules and beats teams ranked in the top 10 during pre-season play — Boise State will have a tough time convincing the BCS gods it is worthy of a shot at the national championship, even if it is the only undefeated team in the NCAA.
And it doesn’t help when the No. 5 team in the nation is only winning by four points at halftime against an un-ranked team.
In the third quarter, Boise State came out hot, scoring a touchdown on the opening drive and a field goal on its second possession.
The Broncos led 28-14 going into the fourth quarter but gave up a long touchdown that brought the Golden Hurricane within one possession, 28-21. Boise State held onto the lead, though, and logged its sixth win of the season.
While the win may not have been strong enough to help BSU in its quest for nationally recognized college football greatness, the university in Idaho has at least taught the nation one thing, as evidenced by signs held up by fans in the crowd at Tulsa:
“Boise Isn’t A State.”
“We looked it up.”
Lifestyle Editor Sean Hart can be contacted at SeanH@argusobserver.com. The views and opinions expressed in this column are not necessarily those of the Argus Observer.
BSU hater wrote on Nov 5, 2009 12:54 PM: