Downtown plan still in a holding pattern
Merchants express misgivings about effort
By Katie Pizza
Argus Observer
Saturday, July 26, 2008 9:42 PM PDT
| |
| KATIE PIZZA | ARGUS OBSERVER
The future downtown area has been the focus of discussion from city officials and merchants alike. Monday, merchant David Eldredge presented a list of 52 business owners and managers whom he said are opposed to any and all revitalization plans for the area. However, Ontario Planning and Zoning Administrator Evan MacKenzie said the time for discussion is not over and would appreciate input from those concerned about the potential revamp. |
Ontario — A plan to revitalize downtown Ontario is still attracting questions, comments and some opposition from local business owners even though the renovation blueprint is still in its preliminary stages.
More controversy erupted over the issue last week at the Ontario City Council session when downtown merchant David Eldredge delivered a petition consisting of 52 total signatures, including his own, which asserted the businesses were opposed to any changes to the downtown area.
Potential changes under the revitalization plan include a park situated in front of the Ontario Train Depot.
One other possible change is for downtown to have a theme, such as a Western or Hispanic motif.
Eldredge, of Eldredge Furniture, also spoke out against the downtown renovation concept at the council session.
However, several business owners Friday said the petition confused them when they signed. Some said they were told downtown merchants would foot the entire bill for the revitalization plan.
“The guy that brought it up told us that they were wanting businesses to pay for everything,” Margie Scott, one of the owners of Ernie’s Electric, situated at 435 S. Oregon St., said.
Ontario Planning and Zoning Administrator Evan MacKenzie said downtown merchants probably would not be tabbed to contribute funding for the project.
“It’s unlikely that it would require an additional financial contribution from downtown property owners,” he said.
The plan to “theme” the downtown area, with a Western or Hispanic motif has some merchants especially uneasy.
“We don’t need to follow each others’ look,” Randy Kuder, owner of the Vacuum Shop, situated at 490 S. Oregon Street said.
Susanne Palmer, one of the owners of the Flower Trunk, situated at 122 S. Oregon St., agreed with this assertion.
“I think now more than ever we need to realize our individuality,” she said. “Because it’s fast disappearing.”
Palmer cited large, boxy, nationally-branded stores as an example of how a community business can lose its individuality.
CITY SEEKS FEEDBACK
MacKenzie said more public input would be required to determine what changes are made to Ontario’s downtown.
After these opinions are gathered, MacKenzie said he would look at funding options. One such option would be to freeze the current property values, with building and remodeling increasing that value.
That increase, MacKenzie said, could potentially go to a fund that would pay for remodeling the downtown area.
Some business owners were also told the potential changes and remodeling would happen all at once, closing off roadways and sidewalks to downtown businesses.
“It would mess up our business,” Red West, who has owned the Belly Buster Sandwich Shop, situated at 512 S. Oregon St., for six years, said. “They are going to block off our streets and tear up our sidewalks. That will put me out of business for quite awhile.”
However, MacKenzie said the remodeling, if there will be any at all, could be a gradual process that would be based on what business owners want to see.
“Today, if you came in for a building permit for downtown, there would not be a lot of requirements,” he said. “You might be required to fix sidewalks outside the business if they are in disrepair. If the community said they think people should do street trees or they should have a certain amount of signage then we can put that in the code.”
He also highlighted another possible outcome.
“They (business owners) need to tell us what they want,” he said Monday. “If they want nothing, we’ll do nothing.”
MacKenzie said he would continue to meet with area business people in order to communicate with them about what they feel the future of Ontario’s downtown should be. He said those who have questions about the downtown revitalization plan should contact him.
“They can call me anytime,” he said. “One of the 52 people (who signed the petition) called me with questions. If each of the people are concerned about the plan, I would encourage them to call me with questions.”
MacKenzie said he sent out 190 notices to businesses on either side of the railroad tracks regarding the downtown revitalization plan.
“I went to almost every business,” MacKenzie said. “I didn’t have a single negative response except for Mr. Eldredge.”
MacKenzie can be reached at (541) 881-3222.
Looking for more local news? Check out the Argus Observer online at www.argusobserver.com
Sam wrote on Aug 9, 2008 1:03 PM:
By the way, somebody, I assume it's the merchant's association, has been doing plantings and improvements. "The back side" looks far better than it did 5 years ago. Kudos. "